Don Rosa Eisner nomination

M.J. Prior M.J.Prior at
Fri Apr 27 22:18:53 CEST 2007

Michiel Prior:

> ... "A Matter of Some Gravity" and the Lo$-series, which 
> were actual Eisner Award winners.

Oops, "A Matter of ..." only got an Eisner nomination!

Joe Torcivia:

> And, if Don  Rosa wins an Eisner for "The Black Knight 
> Glorps Again", I will be happy for him.

If Don Rosa wins an Eisner I'd be happy for him as well, 
but ...

> If you're a fan of this stuff, I'd think you'd prefer the
> Eisner went to Rosa and/or Gemstone than having it go to 
> someone else, under any circumstance!

This is sheer nonsense. It's not like these Awards are a 
kind of baseball competition, where you're rooting for 
either one team or the other. I haven't read any of the 
other competing Short Stories, but since they're nominated 
for Best Short Story, there's a chance I might like some, 
if not all, of the other stories as well. Thus I might be 
equally happy for any of the other guys, should they get 
an Award.


Michiel Prior.

More information about the DCML mailing list