Barks covers question
jvainio@urova.fi
jvainio at urova.fi
Tue Jan 22 21:33:39 CET 2002
In November I visited the editorial offices of the Finnish Aku Ankka. While I
was there up came something that I hadn't really thought about before. They knew
me as something of an art collector and the conversation turned to the two Barks
pieces I have: two blue pencil cover preliminaries, one for Walt Disney's Comics
and Stories #281 ("Feud and Far Away" and a Daisy Duck's Diary story) and one
for Uncle Scrooge #58 ("Giant Robot Robbers"). They're from 1963-1964.
Looking at the published covers I've always thought that they were inked by
someone else than Barks. They don't LOOK like Barks! Yet when I mentioned this
to Markku Kivekas, the Aku Ankka editor, he looked shocked. He challenged me to
prove my point and said that he had never read anywhere anything like that.
I thought about this and went through 'all the usual suspect' book sources.
Nowhere could I find any mention of this. Where did I get this notion?
Now, I'm not an expert on Barks's later work because I don't care too much for
what happened to his drawing style after mid-50s, but did it get THIS bad??
Comparing the blue pencil sketches (and there's a whole section of them
published in the hardcover Carl Barks Library) and the published cover I see a
definite non sequitor: the sketches DO look like Barks's work, but the inked
work DOESN'T. (I'm not talking about all of them, because many clearly were
inked by Barks, but some, like the ones I mentioned).
So, in a nutshell, here's my question to the list: did Barks ink all his covers
himself or was someone else inking them in the later years, based on Barks's
pencils? If someone else inked them, can you point me to a written source saying
that? If Barks inked them himself, can you explain why they look different than
the art in the stories? Did he ink them with his feet??
Even suspecting something like this lead Markku to announce that this would be
the "biggest news since the burning of Rome".
---Jyrki Vainio, Finland (currently U.S.)
More information about the DCML
mailing list