Humperdink Duck's first appearance

[Goofy313g@aol.com]

>>>No, it's a Bill Wright's story: "Grandma Duck", in
>>> Vacation Parade #2, July
>>>1951 (in Italy in TL n. 32, Dec. 1951).

really? I thought the one you just said was an appearance of the Grandpa Duck from the cartoon "No Hunting" (according to Rich's pages) This woulkd make sense : if the grandpa from no hunting appeared, that could be a reason why giovan battista carpi included him in his duck family tree

and as the inducks description of the moore story was "  GD shows the family album to two kids" and Don Rosa told it was a scrapbook scene, I thought it could be the one with Humperdink... Moreover, It was supposed to be a wdc story...


Gilles