Disney's Comics Ratings - C.Barks § R.Scarpa

[Francesco Spreafico]

jeanmarcbano wrote:

> Yes there is a lot of italian stories rated, maybe that is due to the
> fact that there is more european people who have rated the stories
> than american ones? (though Carl Barks has a lot of stories rated and
> well rated);

I actually think that there actually already are many Barks stories at 
the top, so I guess that even though it's likely that most voters may 
still be European, that doesn't really show in the chart!

> personally, i think the amount of votes is rather
> substantial for the Top 100 stories but after the Top 100 there is
> too much stories with one vote.

I think it's not even substantial for the Top 10, too few yet, but 
that's just the beginning, and... well, you have to start with one vote 
to have more later!

> About the list, note that there is two stories versions about the
> Flying Dutchman which are rated : one of Carl Barks which has a
> logical scientific explanation of the mystery, and the Scarpa's
> version which is nearer of a fairy tale.

Well, yes, they're two different stories, so of course they're both 
being voted... I guess I'm missing the point here!

Francesco