collective personality

[Philip Weetman]

>  
> >> I don't like the Beagle Boys having personalities! In the old 
> >> Barks stories, they are very much alike.
>  
> > I think they should have personalities. (...) And anyway, I think
> > Barks gave (or tried to give) the Beagleboys some personalities: He 
> > had a one who was very fond of prunes. And in an other story all 
> > the BB have different skills and education.
> 
> Yeah, I agree that Barks gave them some kind of personality. But I 
> think some recent (Danish) stories make them too "stereotypical" (is 
> that the right word?). Now you have a hungry one, a smart one, etc. I 
> don't think they're very "human" that way.
> 
 well , I'm new here (greetings from Canada) .
  I agree with the above , I'd rather see one good collective 
personality than three cliches . Three cliches might be good enough for 
Ducktales but not in any of the 'serious' disney comics . On the other
hand , if you have three GOOD characters , then that's excellent !

my humble opinion

Philip Weetman